It sounds baffling at first. The most shrill “activists” of the Philippine Opposition gnash their teeth about it and the “rest of the world” — the cadre of journalists and “human rights” activists putting in their two-cents on the matter — lament these “killings”. But the numbers seem to say that Filipinos don’t give a shit about the “shit” that happens. The most recent Social Weather Stations (SWS) poll shows that Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte continues to enjoy the approval of his people.
It is quite evident, that the Opposition sees highlighting the “human toll” of Duterte’s “war on drugs” as a cornerstone of their effort to regain political power. This is a strategy they had been embracing since 2016 when they lost the Philippines to a Mindanaoan for the first time in history. It is also quite evident that this strategy is not working as the latest popularity numbers show and as this year’s mid-term elections revealed.
| SUPPORT INDEPENDENT SOCIAL COMMENTARY! Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us. Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider! Learn more |
Recently, Senator Ronald “Bato” Dela Rosa copped flak when he dismissed the recent death of three-year-old Myca Ulpina in a police shootout with alleged drug personalities as routine “shit” that “happens”. Outrageous remarks, to say the least. Nonetheless, perhaps the real possibility that Filipinos are actually with Dela Rosa should be confronted with a critical mind.
For starters, the absolute tragedy of the violent death of a child should be separated from political agendas, specifically those wielded by people who aim to use such tragedies as fodder for their rhetoric. The key insight needed here is how ordinary Filipinos feel about Ulpina’s death. Is the sentiment strong enough to swing an election? More imporantly, in the context of an Opposition renowned for a habit of weaponising street parliamentarianism, is Ulpina’s death sufficient to move a critical mass of Filipinos to “take to the streets?”
These are important questions in a democracy where the popularity of people and ideas determine who and what wins.
Unfortunately, there is no scientific study backed by unbiased data to answer these strategically-important questions. As far as we can tell, the only information used to interpret how important Ulpina’s death is to political careers comes from biased sources — the sloganeering of Opposition “activists”, the “reports” of liberal Western media, and the shrill pronouncements of self-proclaimed Filipino “thought leaders”.
The stories spun by media may elicit strong emotion, as this “report” from the Sydney Morning Herald shows…
On Tuesday, scores of people joined a 3km funeral procession behind a white hearse, the back of which had a picture of the child wearing a shirt with the word “Pulis” (police).
A priest and funeral workers carried the small casket up some steps and pushed it into a prepared space atop a concrete structure of hundreds of graves built in columns five-high.
Wearing dark sunglasses, Ulpina’s mother fought to contain her anger as a woman police officer approached, shook her hand and offered condolences.
“My daughter is not collateral damage,” she said, as she left the cemetery.
Flavie Villanueva, a former drug user-turned-priest who delivered the mass, said he welcomed calls for a UN investigation, because Duterte and the police were acting “like gods”.
…but reveal very little about how much of an impact they make on the sentiments of the broader community of Filipino voters. There are clues, however, that are conveniently glossed-over: the continued success of the Duterte government in popularity polls, the recent catastrophic loss of the Opposition in this year’s elections, and the consistent failure of “activist” leaders to stir up massive street rallies. All these point to a confronting fact: most Filipinos don’t care.
What foreigners, perhaps, do not understand about the Philippines is that Filipinos are generally desensitised to poverty and even violent death. Indeed, one can even go far as far to assert that the most chi-chi of Opposition “activists” are hypocrites. These are, after all, people who routinely cocoon themselves in airconditioned late model cars and drive by children begging on Manila’s streets everyday. The vast majority of these children live and die on Manila’s streets with hardly a whimper of a slogan from the latte-sipping classes.
Perhaps the only reason Ulpina’s death attracted attention was because of Dela Rosa who very likely represents a hot button for an Opposition group still sore from a colossal election loss. Indeed, as the Herald points out; “[the] child’s death had generated little media attention until Friday, when Ronald dela Rosa, a senator and former top commander of Duterte’s drug war, described the child’s death as collateral damage, and said ‘shit happens’.”
Goes to show, the Opposition not only has a lot more work to do to cobble together a sound election-winning strategy and, more importantly, get smarter when it comes to reading the general public sentiment. The first step in that direction would be to extricate themselves from their little inbred soirees and listen more.
benign0 is the Webmaster of GetRealPhilippines.com.
Senator Bato de la Rosa’s was an opportunity that presented itself and seized by the sanctimonious Opposition to fan mass resentment. Rather than commend him for his honesty in saying “shit happens” without the usual embellishments, the Opposition (or what’s left of it) resorts to manipulation to suit its political agenda. Any death diminishes us but this one does not rise to the level of a storm that would move us. Indeed, we are desensitized to the point we no longer care – that’s because the Opposition never tires resorting to machinations.
(By the way, may I suggest that the “comments” by this “Francisboaps” preceding this one be removed? “Francisboaps” obviously had nothing to say but to market sex and dating sites. This fucking idiot should not be allowed to post here, thank you).
The Philippine has a serious Shabu Drug problem. This started during the administration of Pnoy Aquino. Shabu use and dealing are rampant ever since. The former Secretary of Justice, Leila de Lima, was the biggest Drug Lord in our country. She and her lover, Romy Dayan, were controlling the drug shabu business in our country, with the help of the Chinese Shabu manufacturers.
Leila de Lima, even made the Bilibid National Prison, as a Las Vegas Nevada entertainment center. Complete with drinks, girls and shabu drugs. Bilibid inmates became De Lima’s drug lords.
Nasty and vicious things happen in a war on drugs. Drug dealers and Police shoot each other. Drug dealers shoot one another, for drug territories; and other various reasons.
We grieve for the death of this child. Unfortunately, the opposition is using it as a “political fodder” , against Pres. Durterte. The opposition feed foreign media : fake news and disinformation; making some foreign human rights activists and foreign do gooders to join the chorus, to remove Duterte.
We don’t want foreigners to meddle in our internal political affairs. The opposition will always use any means in any way to remove Duterte; because time is running out for them !
The need to survive outweighs grief. Having misaligned agendas makes it really hard to see the uncomplicated truth. Mr. De la Rosa shouldn’t let an unproductive Opposition distract him from doing what needs to be done. It’s been 3 years and still nothing from the self-righteous bunch.
Sentiments are many a times much above reality. All are aware of reality but blinded by faith and faith has always led to many a myths become reality. It is character that should be the sole measure of judgement in the society of thinking humanity, and nothing short of that would do.
I’m expecting this to end like the that worthless Arbitration Court backed by the US, a waste of time and money and just an impotent and shallow PR victory for the “International Community” that will not do anything but give praise to those who voted Yes and the UN who enjoys looking for soft targets to keep up their influence.
“Collateral damage” maybe a right words for the unfortunate event that had happened, but not the right words to speak in public especially when the opposition elites are all listening and just waiting for mistakes to happen, and there will be mistakes, because they are counting on mistakes, no matter how small it is, controversy is their expertise, they can make a mountain out of a mole.
Forgot to add this bit, in the Liberal-Progressive political thought, there’s this contempt and hatred for your fellow countrymen who do not subscribe to your political beliefs to the point where they’d rather cater to foreigners than their countrymen, you can see this North America and Europe. Of course these busybodies would rather be seen as “brave” in fighting the good fight in a soft target like the Philippines.